200 Years of People v. Philips and Religious Freedom

William Sampson, the Irish Protestant who argued People v. Phillips; A sketch of old St. Peter's Roman Catholic Church on Barclay Street in NY.
William Sampson, the Irish Protestant who argued People v. Phillips; A sketch of old St. Peter's Roman Catholic Church on Barclay Street in NY.

By Adam Farley, Editorial Assistant
April / May 2013

1813 brought the first test of the right of free religious practice and expression in the United States. The famous case, People v. Philips, which eventually solidified the priest-penitent evidentiary privilege that protects the privacy of information given during confession, was argued in New York City on behalf of the growing Catholic population by the exiled Irish Protestant William Sampson.

Sampson, having seen the legacy of religious intolerance in Ireland, argued that U.S. law should not look across the Atlantic for legal precedent in dealing with Catholics. He argued the case on behalf of the trustees of St. Peter’s Roman Catholic Church on Barclay Street in New York.

In commemoration of the case, Glucksman Ireland House (GIH) at New York University has organized “Religious Freedom in America, 1813 to 2013: Bicentennial Reflections on People v. Philips,” a weekend of events that examine the intersections of Ireland and America in the foundation of our national culture.

On April 12th, the case itself will be dramatically re-enacted at Glucksman House, adapted for the stage from Sampson’s own accounts by playwright Steve DiUbaldo.

Following the staged reading, Saturday the 13th brings a day-long symposium to GIH, featuring numerous interdisciplinary speakers, including retired Irish High Court Justice Bryan McMahon and Professor Walter J. Walsh of the University of Washington, Seattle, School of Law, and panels to discuss the legacy of the case and the ways in which it is still relevant to contemporary issues.

On Sunday the 14th, a morning pilgrimage will be made to Green-Wood Cemetery in Brooklyn to pay respects to the graves of Sampson and the judge who ruled in his favor, New York City Mayor De Witt Clinton.

For further information, contact Miriam Nyhan by email or by phone at 212.998.3953.

Leave a Reply


More Articles

U.S. President John F. Kennedy is greeted by an enthusiastic crowd of children and nuns from the Convent of Mercy, as he arrives from Dublin by helicopter at Galway's sports ground, Ireland, June 29, 1963. (AP Photo)
Irish Film Institute Brings the Past Online

The Irish Film Institute has digitized over 1,200 minutes of Irish cinema, documentary, and public information films...


The dedication of California’s first memorial to the Irish Hunger. (Photo: Loretta McCarthy)
California’s First Irish Hunger Memorial

The community of Eugene, California welcomed the state’s first Irish Hunger Memorial at its dedication ceremony in...


Donors and volunteers who helped fund the plaque and restoration of Margaret Place in New Orleans. (Photo: Monumental Task Committee, Inc. / Facebook)
“Mother of Orphans” Sculpture Renewed

Since July 9, 1884, a sculpture of humanitarian Margaret Haughery, otherwise known as “The Mother of Orphans” (June...


Patrick's of Pratt Street in Baltimore, allegedly the oldest Irish bar in the U.S., has closed.
America’s Oldest Irish Pub Closes

The oldest Irish pub in America shut its doors once and for all in September. Patrick’s of Pratt Street, a tourist...