Boston College IRA Tapes Get a Full Hearing

Boston College Burns Library, where the Belfast Project archives are housed.
Boston College Burns Library, where the Belfast Project archives are housed.

By Molly Ferns, Editorial Assistant
February / March 2012

In recent weeks, the case between Boston College and the U.S. government (working on behalf of the British government and a body rumored to be Police Service of Northern Ireland) has taken a few important turns. The case, which will now be given a full hearing on January 27th, began nine months ago, when Boston College was subpoenaed to release its collection of oral histories and interviews with former IRA members and paramilitaries. The collection, part of the college’s larger Belfast Project, was gathered between 2001 and 2006 by journalist  and former IRA member Anthony McIntyre and Bronx-based Ed Moloney. The interviews were given under the condition that they would be confidential, and that none of the materials would be released until after the interviewees were deceased.

The subpoena initially called for all of the interviews to be released, but was then revised to request only materials that referenced the 1972 murder of Jean McConville. Particular emphasis has been placed on the taped interview with ex-IRA member Dolours Price, in which it is believed Price discusses Sinn Fein leader Gerry Adams’ involvement in the McConville murder. In another interview with the Belfast Project, Brendan Hughes, a now deceased ex-IRA member and close associate of Gerry Adams, claimed that Adams ordered McConville’s murder because she was allegedly spying on the IRA for the British Army.

In mid-December, U.S. District Court Judge William C. Young conducted an in-camera review of a portion of the tapes, which the college had called for. On December 22nd, he gave the college a deadline of December 30th to release the tapes. Though the college failed to meet this deadline, the materials were handed over to the court soon after. “These are serious allegations, and they weigh strongly in favor of disclosing the confidential information,” said Judge Young. His decision was reported to be based on a treaty that binds the U.S. and U.K. to share information relevant to ongoing criminal investigations.

Though the college did not appeal Judge Young’s ruling, it expressed disappointment, saying that it “could have a chilling effect because people could be reluctant to participate in oral histories moving forward.”

Lawyers working on behalf of  Moloney and McIntyre then submitted a motion to forestall Judge Young’s decision, on the grounds that it was a violation of academic freedom. They also claim that handing over the tapes might undermine the Northern Ireland peace process and threaten the safety of all those involved.

The U.S. Department of Justice accepted their motion, scheduling the full hearing. As the case has garnered significant media attention on both sides of the Atlantic and throughout the island of Ireland, the fate of the tapes will be closely monitored and dissected in the weeks to come.

Leave a Reply




 

Share



More Articles

Irish American Partnership President and CEO Joe Leary (left) and Irish America magazine co-founder Patricia Harty (right) with Boston Mayor Marty Walsh (center) holding the Waterford House of Crystal 2014 Irish American of the Year award. PHOTOS by Harry Brett.
Boston Mayor Marty Walsh: Irish American of the Year

  A version of this post originally appeared on Irish Massachusetts. A transcript of Mayor Walsh’s...

More

Mayor of Boston Marty Walsh
Boston’s Man of the People: Marty Walsh

There was world renowned musician Yo-Yo Ma on center stage, playing an audacious solo of Danny Boy on his cello before...

More

Three of the heroes being honored: MBTA Officer Richard Donohue, Ken Casey of the Dropkick Murphys, and Lt. J. Paul Vance, Commanding Officer, CT State Police Public Information Office.
Irish Heroes of Boston Marathon and Sandy Hook to be Honored in Boston

The Irish Emigrant newspaper, in partnership with IrishCentral and Irish America magazine, is proud to announce the...

More

Jane Richard. Photo: The Richard Family.
Boston Marathon: The Road to Recovery

Jane Richard is dancing again. Jane Richard, the tiny Irish step dancer from Dorchester, who lost her left leg in the...

More