Christmas Then and Now

Every Christmas Morning Now, Every Christmas Morning Then

Every Christmas morning now is full of every Christmas morning then, and in the old unaccountable unfolding of memory I can’t rest on a single time when it all took shape, but this is the story of a suburban Christmas, an Irish Christmas, a Dublin Christmas, a Christmas in the four-bedroom house where I spent my first twenty-one years and where, thirty-nine years on, I still return no matter where I happen to be.

This story doesn’t have any snow-covered belfries, high-legged horses in the stone-walled fields, snowstorms walling us in, or even single-bar electric heaters, or terrible high-rise lifts that do not work, or suicides, or crazy aunts dropping lit cigarettes into the deep folds of the sofa. Rather, this is a story of an ordinary Christmas in an ordinary house at an ordinary time in the extra-ordinary glamour of childhood.  

Every corner is a world. My world back then, in the early 1970s, was a house on the corner of Clonkeen Road and South Park, near Deansgrange, where I used to think nothing that bad happened or, if it happened at all, it never much happened to me. 

I had, I suppose, a novelist’s worst childhood – it was happy.  

Up from the cold dark of winter days, Christmas days unfolded into Christmas Eve, a dolphin-leap of delight. Pieces of holly was clipped from the bush in the front garden and put in the front hallway. Mistletoe was sellotaped crookedly over the front door – eight years old, I sidled away, thinking I’d have to kiss my sisters, and a kiss from a sister was worse than no Christmas at all. I hid under the stairs, eyeing the tins of Afternoon Tea biscuits that were hidden away for the holidays. The postman whistled up the driveway – what was it about postman that always made them want to whistle? He dropped his freight of Christmas cards through the letterbox: relatives in Birmingham, my aunt in New Jersey, our cousins in Derry. Last year’s cards were strung on lengths of red crepe paper around the house. I jumped and tried to slap the Three Wise Men, then ran upstairs to ransack the cupboards to see what presents I could find deep amid the fragrant dark of my father’s suits. 

The turkey at least gave me a boy’s adventure – we bought the bird from the butcher shop down the road, stuffed it in the trunk of the Vauxhall Victor and brought it home through the rain. The bird was dead of course but still fully intact, and my sister and I made gobble-gobble sounds as it flopped out on the kitchen table. The animal still needed its neck chopped and the next morning it was taken into the back garden, flopped out on a piece of wooden board, and taken care of by my father, not with an axe but with a big black-handled knife sawing slowly through the sinews. We peeped down from the gap in the upstairs curtains. I whispered to my younger brother that it was his neck on the block — or was that my older brother whispered it to me? And then the turkey was brought indoors and plopped in the sink and jokes were made about who’s flying now, and don’t be pulling my leg, and who was going to stuff it? 

And then my mother got down to work, kneading the breadcrumbs and oiling the deep oven-blackened pans. She hummed her songs as she moved through the kitchen, apron strings tied in a bow. 

It was Christmas Eve and the darkness fell with a thump. 

Shoes to be polished.  Home-made puddings to be taken down from the top shelf. Mince pies arranged in last year’s biscuit boxes. The carefully-iced Christmas cake was taken out from the room under the stairs. I had to have a bath of all things – the second in a week, no grumbling allowed. And then I padded downstairs in my soft warm pyjamas to write the note for Santa. Dear Santa I want a Stoke City jersey and peace in the world. We put three mince pies on a plate, some fruitcake, and poured a good measure of whiskey, the bottle label which I loved, three swallows in flight, and then it was up the stairs thinking that I know why Santa is fat but how come he never gets drunk?  If he has a whiskey in every house on our road then surely he’d at least start singing?  And while I’m at it, how come his arse never gets stuck in the chimney?  Maybe I should tell him to go easy on the Paddy’s and cut back on the mince pies?  It was questions like these that occupied my mind and sent me to bed quite sure I’d never ever ever fall asleep, never, because of the tinkling of bells outside, because of the whoosh of wind, never, because of the creaking of floorboards downstairs, never, because of, ever… never,  never — Christmas Day rose with a thin reef of stars over the suburbs. 

I pulled back the sheets and tiptoed on the cold of the bedroom floor.  Outside the grass was wet with dew and there was not a hint of snow on the ground, but who cared? “Mum!, Dad!  Get up! It’s Christmas!” Down the stairs my younger brother, Ronan, and I leaped at least eighteen steps at a time — quite an achievement since there were only fourteen. Onto the cold kitchen linoleum he and I stepped, no shoes, no socks, no slippers. Around us the whole house had begun to crackle awake.  My older brother Sean loped down the stairs with his long hair hanging over one eye. My older sisters, Siobhan and Oonagh, would soon erupt in a tearaway scramble for the bathroom but right then they were playing hide-and-go-seek with sleep. Up the stairs Ronan and I went to terrorise them. 

“Hurry up, hurry up, it’s Christmas! Last one up’s even uglier than the other one.” 

Christmas morning — the white radiators clicked and the house began to heat: a tick that was beyond the time of any clock.

Mum and Dad began to stir into that lovely silence that surrounded them every  Christmas morning and they came downstairs in dressing gowns to guide Ronan and I towards the fireplace. There was only one chimney, but it backed into two rooms, the living room and the dining room. Slowly we turned the handle on the door. My father peeked, my mother stepped back. Terrible theatrics at first, since Santa Claus had a penchant of moving from one fireplace to the other – “No, oh no! Santa didn’t come! Look, it’s empty!” – and then we turned the corner into the living room where he had, God-bless-him, eaten not only the mince pies and the fruitcake but he’d taken good care of the large glass of Powers too, and there were no thoughts anymore of Santa being drunk, impossible, the whiskey had only made him warm, no doubt, sure he needed a good dollop to stave off the cold.  Not only that but he left a thank-you note, and I leaped about in my red and white Stoke City shirt screaming that I had been a good boy after all, imagine that, I had, and I leaped up for a header and the Three Wise Men and their crepe paper tumbling to the ground.

Yes, we jumped around like prayers in an air raid, which reminded us, sadly that we had to go to Mass before opening the other presents which were stacked by the tree in enormous piles. First things first. We put Baby Jesus was put in the crib. We wouldn’t ever tell a soul, but Jesus looked a bit like Tarzan in his loincloth. Soon enough he might start swinging off the Christmas tree. Using the tinsel for vine. A flush of blasphemy to my cheeks. 

A candle was lit and there was a moment when the holy was hailed. And then it was on with the best clothes, neatly ironed, and we piled outside into the still-dark morning, cold enough to stun the bones in our cheeks. We jumped, all seven of us, into the gold Vauxhall, no seat belts, no car seats and yes those dolphin-dreams of the rest of the day. It was an early mass in Cabinteely, eight o’clock. Father George was famous for his lightening speed and grumpiness and all homily long he droned on in a language we couldn’t understand. So we ignored his shiny bald dome and his corporal’s voice and his pot-bellied tunic and his hell and damnation and instead we dreamed of the presents under the tree until he slurred “Peace be with you,” because we knew the mass was almost finished, only the Communion was left and then, finally, gloriously, “Mass has ended, go in peace to love and serve the Lord.”

Afterwards the light was of the quality that no dark could ever match.  We skipped through Cabinteely Village towards the car, slid in and bantered all the way home, wondering how that poor turkey was doing now.  

Christmas breakfast was a time to watch the clock turn.

Sizzling bacon.  Eggs.  Steaming tea.  Toast slathered in too much butter.  And strangely there was no kicking under the table, no belching across the breakfast plates, no licking of the opposing sibling’s teaspoon, there was harmony in the household since we were held aloft by the prospect of presents, stacked this-way-and-that under the shedding tree. “Let’s go!” And we gathered around, in the fanciest room in the house, opening the presents one-by-one.  The fashionable orange sweatshirt (or so I thought). The Shoot! annual and Roy of the Rovers book and a new Subutteo team.  A bike for Ronan.  A new perfume for Siobhan and a soft clip on the ear for telling her that now she’d finally smell good. A Dolphin Discs token for Sean. And a scream of delight when Oonagh opened up a package to reveal a Bay City Rollers scarf, of all things, yes, Bay City Rollers. 

~  

There are no days more full than those we go back to.  

All those Christmases collide into each other and my memory is decorated by a series of mirrors flashing light into chambers of sound and color – the blue of the sky  (even when it wasn’t blue, it seemed blue), the briquettes sparking red-layered on the fire, the crinkling of the ridiculous yellow paper hats at dinner time, my mother singing at the stove, The boys are all mad about Nelly, the dining room table perfectly laid out, the silverware we’d see only once a year, the bad jokes in the crackers, and the other jokes as dinner unfolded, the shilling coins wrapped in wax paper and buried inside the plum pudding, the deep pour of wine into my father’s glass, my mother’s head thrown back in laughter, the light outside gradually dimming, a bromide of sorts, and the laughter moving to deep silence at three in the afternoon when we leaned up against one another like fat old tires, full of turkey and gravy and trifle and god knows how many slices of plum pudding. 

Still there was enough room left to break the seal on the tin of Quality Street, and then we clicked the batteries into the horse-racing game and the day stretched out in time, so many hours that it seemed endless, infinite, elastic.

Like the afterimage of a light that only by closing my eyes I can see, I glimpse my childhood as it was, and good it was, and spoiled it was, and safe it was, and generous it was, when we did not lack the peace of simple things, when happiness came to us unasked, when there was no end to what we could imagine, when even Santa Claus brought us the possibility of peace. Still they rise and flash, those Christmas days, without apology, without heartbreak or revelation or dilemma — maybe to describe such happiness is to diminish it, but is it enough to say that by the end of the evening we slept and we dreamed.   

~~~~ 

My father once told me that the best gift he ever got as a child, back in the 1930s, was a white donkey. But they lived in a small cottage in Foxrock and had nowhere to keep the animal. Three days after Christmas the donkey was sold again. It was a three-day gift, but he didn’t mind, not even when the money went into my Grandfather’s pocket. 

What momentary beauty and sadness: every world with a corner.   

And yet I have never thought that the gift, or the story, or even the donkey itself ends there. Rather my mother and father brought that same gift to all the Christmases they gave to us. I used to wonder how I could thank my folks for those days, in the uncomplicated suburbs of Dublin, but in recent years I have learned that there is no way to thank them, really, other than to try to make these moments for my own children, in what I hope are (for them at least) the uncomplicated towers of New York, so that they get passed on in the deep grammar of memory – there are times I am sure I can hear on a cold snowy day the hooves of a white donkey clopping along at the far end of Central Park, and why not?  Every Christmas morning now is full of every Christmas morning then. 

Colum McCann is the author of six novels and three collections of stories. His novel, TransAtlantic, was long-listed for the Man Booker Prize in 2013, and his previous novel, Let the Great World Spin, won the National Book Award, the International IMPAC Dublin Literary  Award, and was a New York Times bestseller. Colum McCann’s non-fiction book “American Mother”was published by Etruscan Press on March 5, 2024, and earned him worldwide attention. His new novel Twist will be published by Bloomsbury on March 2, 2025.