Joe McGarrity:
De Valera’s Man in America

Joseph  McGarrity greeting Countess Constance Markievicz at Broad Street Station, Philadelphia in April 1922.
Joseph McGarrity greeting Countess Constance Markievicz at Broad Street Station, Philadelphia in April 1922.

By Sean Cronin, Contributor
February / March 2016

“…the general awakening that was taking place in Ireland seemed to make us forget everything else for the time and think only of the fight in prospect.”

– Joe McGarrity

Joe McGarrity was éamon de Valera’s right hand man in America and was once described by poet Padraic Colum as “a gallowglass ready to swing a battleaxe with his long arms.” It was an apt description for the old warrior.

McGarrity was born in Carrickmore, County Tyrone, in 1874. Legend has it that as a penniless 16-year-old he walked to Dublin, boarded a cattle boat to Liverpool disguised as a drover, and sailed to America on someone else’s ticket. He settled in Philadelphia and made a fortune selling liquor and real estate.

He joined Clan na Gael, the Fenian movement in America, and devoted his life to the cause of Irish independence. He conferred the title “President of the Irish Republic” on Eamon de Valera when the latter landed in New York in June 1919 to seek U.S. support for the Irish Republic declared by the first Dáil in January 1919.



De Valera’s title was “President of Dáil Eireann.” Joe argued that Americans had no idea what “Dill Eireann” meant but that “President of the Irish Republic” was analogous to the title “President of the United States” and its use by de Valera would make that clear.

Henceforth, McGarrity was de Valera’s first lieutenant in America and a fount of wisdom on all problems until the mid-1930s when the ex-President of the Irish Republic suppressed the I.R.A. under the Offenses Against the State Act and used military courts to jail them. McGarrity ended all contact with de Valera.

Almost two decades earlier, McGarrity had exposed a plot against de Valera by his enemies in New York, which, if successful, would have forced his return to Dublin in disgrace and ended in his defeat because he had incurred the wrath of Judge Daniel Cohalan and the aged Fenian veteran John Devoy as Dáil Eireann’s spokesman in the U.S.

Devoy, writing in the Gaelic American, denounced de Valera for a published interview with a British correspondent in which the politician had said Britain should declare a “Monroe Doctrine” for Ireland, as the U.S. had done for Cuba. Devoy’s point was that the Monroe Doctrine had made Cuba a dependency of the United States. De Valera, however, seemed ignorant of Cuba’s real status.

Program for Friends of Ireland  Freedom dinner  honoring éamon de Valera in Philadelphia  on October 1, 1919.

Program for Friends of Ireland Freedom dinner honoring éamon de Valera in Philadelphia on October 1, 1919.

Discussion of the issue at a large meeting in the Waldorf-Astoria Hotel turned into an indictment and trial of de Valera. McGarrity, who had letters proving this was a plot, saved the day for de Valera. “From the day I landed in America, I had the absolute cooperation of Joe McGarrity,” de Valera declared. “If I were dying tomorrow and had the power to hand over the cause of Ireland to one man, that man would be Joseph McGarrity “

On December 9, 1920, on the eve of his return home to Ireland, de Valera did exactly that. He nominated “Joseph McGarrity of 3714 Chestnut St., Philadelphia, as my substitute, entitled to act with all my powers in case I am incapacitated by imprisonment or death or any other cause. I anticipate to be absent from the U.S. for some time. During my absence I wish you to act for me as Trustee of Dill Eireann in regard to such funds as are at present in the US.”

McGarrity died on September 4, 1940. ♦

2 Responses to “Joe McGarrity:
De Valera’s Man in America”

  1. andrew says:

    A point of correction. It is Dáil Eireann.

  2. michael p mcgarrity says:

    1. Joe and DeV did NOT sever all ties in the mid-30s.
    2. Joseph died on 5 August 1940 in Philadelphia of throat cancer.

Leave a Reply


More Articles

Peter Thompson poses with a rifle and bayonet. (Photo: Missoulian)
Weekly Comment:
Irish America and WWI: The Story of Peter Thompson

April 6, 2017 marks the 100th anniversary of the entrance of the United States into World War I. Irish Americans were...


Damian Shiels.
The Forgotten Irish Remembered at U.S. National Archives

Irish archeologist Damian Shiels, who specializes in what he calls “conflict archeology,” will launch his new book...


Mother Jones at the White House, September 26, 1924. (Photo: Library of Congress)
Wild Irish Women:
Mother Jones

Irish-born American labor leader Mother Jones was once known as the “most dangerous woman in...


Eviction from the Vandeleur Estate in  Kilrush, Co. Clare,  c. 1888. Photos courtesy Sean Sexton.
Window on the Past:
The Battering Ram (Photos)

Sean Sexton’s photographic archive, considered the finest privately-held collection of Irish photographs in the...